Are You Drowning in CRE Spreadsheets?

How To Go From Chaos to Clarity in Commercial Real Estate Reporting

by Trevor Calton

I’ve seen this story play out over and over again. Different companies, different teams, but the same broken systems.

The Situation:

When I first sit down with the leadership teams, the frustration is obvious. Reports don’t match. Portfolio data is scattered across dozens of spreadsheets. Forecasts are reactive at best. Strategic decisions are made on ‘gut instinct’ instead of reliable data and analysis. And nobody can tell whether the numbers they are seeing are the most current, or the most accurate.

Sound familiar?

These aren’t failing teams. These are smart, committed professionals doing their best with the tools they have. But those tools, namely Excel, weren’t designed for a billion-dollar real estate portfolio or a national mortgage bank originating thousands of loans per month. These firms need complex reporting and real-time decision-making, but the tools don’t keep up.

Spreadsheets are for analyzing information, not storing valuable data.

They weren’t just outgrowing spreadsheets. They were falling behind in risk, reporting, and readiness.

The Problem:

Let’s break it down. These organizations face:

• Inconsistent reports across teams and time periods

• No centralized system for portfolio oversight

• Manual entry and copy-paste reconciliation for every cycle

• Limited forecasting ability due to data lag

• Rising risk exposure, especially during transitions or audits

Each team or department has its own process, its own version of “truth,” and its own spreadsheet template. As one stakeholder put it:

“If that person leaves, we’re not sure how to rebuild half of these reports.”

I’ve seen this pattern too many times. Most organizations don’t realize how much time, trust, and opportunity they’re losing… until it breaks.

The Project: Enterprise Systems Overhaul

I am brought in as a strategic consultant to lead a full systems modernization of their asset and financial reporting infrastructure. A typical engagement lasts 9-18 months and includes:

Phase 1: Discovery & Assessment

• Conduct a full audit of existing workflows, tools, and reporting processes

• Identify active independent versions of portfolio data across departments

• Map cross-team dependencies and internal pain points

Phase 2: Planning & Buy-In

• Lead vendor evaluation and selection. In one recent case, MRI Investment Central was chosen for its integration and scalability.

• Create a phased implementation roadmap with internal milestones and ownership

• Align IT, finance, asset management, and executive leadership around common outcomes

Phase 3: Implementation

• Manage all data migration, systems integration, and custom configurations

• Work side-by-side with internal teams to replace patchwork workflows with clean, automated processes

• Facilitate training and change management to ensure adoption, not just installation

Phase 4: Documentation & Sustainability

• Author a comprehensive workflow handbook, including policies, procedures, SOPs, and more

• Build custom reporting templates and dashboards

• Transition from external dependency to internal ownership

The Results:

Before:

• Monthly reporting cycle: 3 to 4 weeks

• Data errors: Pervasive

• Forecasting: Reactive

• Staff time reconciling data: More than half

After:

• Reporting cycle: Less than 3 days

• Data errors: 99% Reduction

• Forecasting: real-time and forward-looking

• Reconciliation time: Less than 10%

More than just speed or accuracy, the teams gained confidence.

1. They stopped second-guessing their data.

2. They started planning proactively.

3. And they finally had a system that matched the scale and complexity of the organization.

Lessons from the Field

These aren’t software projects. They are business transformations with systems at the center.

We’ve led multiple projects like this, across sectors and portfolio types, and every time, the same pattern emerges: Smart people. Hardworking teams. And a system that’s outlived its usefulness.

If you’re still relying on spreadsheets for enterprise reporting, you’re not alone, but you’re likely behind. And the longer you wait to fix it, the harder the pivot becomes.

Final Takeaway

When your finance and reporting systems are built on sand, you can’t scale. But when you replace chaos with clarity, everything else accelerates: decisions, accountability, communication, confidence.

You can’t run, or scale, a billion dollar company without an enterprise database system.

If your team is stuck in the noise, broken reports, outdated tools, or systems you’ve outgrown, let’s talk.

We help commercial real estate firms move from chaos to clarity.

---

Trevor Calton is the President of Evergreen Capital Advisors and founder of Real Estate Finance Academy. A longtime industry veteran and former Professor of Real Estate Finance, he has analyzed, acquired, or sold more than $5 billion of commercial real estate assets, financed over 500 commercial investment properties, and overseen the asset management of over 6000 units of multifamily housing.